In the pie vs. cake debate, I am always firmly in the cake camp. No matter how delicious the pie, a piece of cake frosted in buttercream always wins.
But I do concede to pie every once in a while. Thanksgiving—obviously—is a pie holiday. In fact, I'd say pie pretty much runs the show on that particular day. But I'll also give pie the summer season. Seasonal fruit = killer dessert.
This weekend, we had two dinner invitations—one to friends for a barbecue and one to my mother-in-law's. I volunteered to bring dessert to both and began to think of light, summery, not-too-sweet desserts.
For the first dinner (gourmet burgers and grilled veggies) I went with key lime pie. It's been my experience it's almost always a winner with everyone. And if you don't like it ... give it another try. It's worth it.
The problem with key lime pie is, there are a million variations on the recipe. There are frozen key lime pies, cheesecake versions, fluffy ones ... the list goes on. For mine, I just wanted the standard, creamy-tangy filling with a graham cracker crust.
So I do what I do when I always want the gold standard, I turned to
Cook's Illustrated. If you aren't familiar with this magazine (I have their 1,000-recipe cookbook, too), the deal is this: they test everything. And then they write about it—in depth. So basically you reap the benefits of someone else doing all the homework. It rarely fails me.
Right away I spot areas in the recipe where I can cut corners. Make my own graham cracker crust? Much easier to just buy one. Squeeze the juice out of the limes? Why? I can just buy a bottle of key lime juice.
However, I try to be a purist when it comes to baking and I resisted the urge to cheat and did as the
Cook's Illustrated gurus told me. The result was perfect. It was tart, but balanced by the buttery, sweet crust. The pie was creamy and thick, a texture unique to key lime. And did I mention easy? This is one of the simplest desserts I've ever made—but tastes like hours of work.
Below is the recipe with my notes:
Key Lime Pie
Lime Filling
• 4 teaspoons grated zest and 1/2 cup strained juice from 3 or 4 limes
*Laurel's Note: I had to use 5 limes and half a lemon (ran out of limes) to get a 1/2 cup. But, I also didn't have a juicer, so I don't think I got as much juice out. I also think the the lemon actually made the pie better since I was using regular limes, not key limes.
• 4 large egg yolks
• 1 (14-oz) can sweetened condensed milk
Graham Cracker Crust
• 9 graham crackers
• 2 tbsp sugar
• 5 tbsp melted butter
*Laurel's Note: Seriously, just make this. Don't buy a pre-made crust. This crust is so buttery and crunchy—it is truly the perfect complement to the pie.
Whipped Cream Topping
• 3/4 cup chilled cream
• 1/4 cup powdered sugar
*Laurel's Note: Ok, true confession. I bought Redi-Whip and squirted it on. I paid the price for my negligence, too. It was the light version and practically disintegrated before it was served. Although the whipped topping is nice, it's not totally necessary.
Instructions: Make the filling first so it can thicken while you make the crust. Whisk zest and yolks together until tinted green. Beat in condensed milk, then juice. Set aside at room temperature to thicken (about 30 minutes).
Process graham crackers in food processor until fine. Pulse in sugar until combined. Pour in warm melted butter and pulse until combined. Take out and press evenly into a pie pan. Bake 15-18 minutes at 325.
Let crust cool and then pour filling into crust. Bake 15-17 minutes at 325. Let cool to room temperature and then refrigerate until well chilled, at least 3 hours.
Whip the cream with sugar (use a hand-held mixer) and garnish pie or just dollop on each slice.
Adapted from The New Best Recipe from the editors of Cook's Illustrated.
Summer Berry Pie
After all that key lime perfection, I was reluctant to stray from such a winner. I almost whipped up key lime number two for our Sunday-night dinner with mom, but as I was flipping through the
Cook's Illustrated cookbook, a recipe for Summer Berry Pie caught my eye and my curiosity got the best of me. And boy am I glad it did.
My mother-in-law is pretty picky about dessert. She's not, by nature, a sweets person, so finding a dessert she likes is challenging. Not only did she eat her pie, she also let me leave her some leftovers!
Once again, the tart/sweet combo was a winner. This time, it was the berries of summer that lent a little tartness and a lot of freshness to the pie. Juicy, refreshing and light—I can't think of a better way to end a warm summer evening of dining al fresco.
Here's the recipe!
Summer Berry Pie
Graham Cracker Crust: See above
Berry Filling
• 2 cups raspberries
• 2 cups blackberries
• 2 cups blueberries
• 1/2 cup sugar
• 3 tbsp cornstarch
• 1/8 tsp salt
• 1 tbsp lemon juice
• 2 tbsp red currant jelly (or whatever you have)
Whipped Topping: 2 cups, see recipe above
Instructions
Make the crust just like the key lime pie. Combine fruit in colander, wash and lay out on a towel to dry.
In a food processor, puree 2 1/2 cups of mixed berries until smooth. Strain through a mesh strainer into a saucepan (to get rid of seeds).
Whisk together sugar, cornstarch and salt and then whisk into puree. Bring puree to a boil on medium heat, stirring constantly with wooden spoon. When the mixture reaches a boil and the consistency of pudding, remove from heat and stir in lemon juice. Set aside and let cool slightly.
While puree is cooling, place remaining berries in bowl. Heat jelly in small saucepan to melt. Drizzle it over berries in bowl and gently toss with spatula to coat.
Pour berry puree into crust and distribute glazed berries over puree. Gently press them in.
Loosely cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least three hours. Top with whipped cream!
*Laurel's Note: This pie was messy to serve! I think I put too many berries on top, which may have been part of the problem. But it was soooooo good that nobody cared.
Adapted from The New Best Recipe from the editors of Cook's Illustrated.